We've been talking a lot in class about concussions in the NFL and the legal ramifications. This got me wondering on what influence these court cases might have on other violent sports, like hockey. What I found was very interesting. There are so many similarities: situations, injuries, and tragic deaths of players later diagnosed with CTE. A wrongful death lawsuit has even been filed recently against the NHL for the drug addiction and suicide of a former "Enforcer" by the family of the player.
But the reaction by the other formal NHLers is very different than the NFLers. Many players don't actually blame their injuries on the league, in fact the acknowledge the leagues proactive nature on this issue. Keith Primeau, who made his living being a gritty player who suffered 4 documented concussions during his 15 year career in the NHL, does not blame the NHL for his continuing long term health issues. Despite being approached by several attorneys looking to jump on a similar bandwagon to the NFL's lawsuits, he isn't interested in pursuing any.
The league has been very proactive history with concussions, starting in 1997 trying to protect their players. Now, these could be similar claims to the NFL when they were/are in denial, but I think it's different. Research and rule changes and increased education have been made to try to make hockey players more safe.
It is interesting to think that the paths and opinions of players can be so different in sports that are so similar in their violent nature. Even with the same injuries and diseases present in both sports, it is interesting that the players in one sport feel much more inclined to seek legal retribution.
So does this mean that the NFL lawsuits have opened the doors to lawsuits in any violent sport, or just more lawsuits for football? Can we view the NFL cases as a precedent for all cases or do we have to look at each sport on a case-by-case basis?
http://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/nhl/2013/09/30/nhl-concussions-players-keith-primeau-gary-bettman/2898689/
http://www.corboydemetrio.com/news-414.html
http://articles.latimes.com/2013/may/13/sports/la-sp-sn-derek-boogaard-lawsuit-nhl-20130513